Black vs. Brown Eyeliner: Which One is the Better Option for Your Eyes?

The color of your eyeliner is the first thing people notice when looking at you in the morning. It can take your look from “I was about to be late” to “I am hella ready, let’s go.” The color shade you use for your eyes matters on how you look. So which color is better for your eyes for everyday use?

The answer to this question depends on your eye color and application techniques. In this article, we will talk about the difference between black and brown eyeliner. We will also dive into which types of eyeliners suit you based on your eye color and other considerations.

Photo by George Milton on Pexels

What is the Difference Between Brown vs. Black Eyeliner?

There are two critical differences between brown and black eyeliner.

The first difference has to do with color tones. Brown eyeliner is generally softer and more natural looking than black eyeliner. It creates various looks, from a smoky eye to a more defined cat eye. Black eyeliner is harsher and more dramatic, making it a better choice for evenings or special occasions.

The second difference between brown and black eyeliner is in how they are applied. Many people may find it difficult to create dramatic lines with brown eyeliners. It would be easier to achieve those dramatic lines using black eyeliner because it’s not as gentle-looking.

Preference-wise, black eyeliner is usually the popular choice by people with dark skin tones as it will not look too harsh on their skin. People with light skin tones usually prefer brown eyeliner as it will not make their eyes look washed out or too dark.

How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for Your Eye Color?

Picking the right eyeliner is dependent of your eye color. You also might want to consider a few extra factors, including the type of eyeliner you want (pencil or liquid) and the intensity you prefer.

Liquid liners are more intense and vibrant than pencil liners. So a pencil will be the best option if you want a softer look that is not too dark!

Pencil eyeliners come in various colors, but they all have one thing in common. They can smudge easily, so you might have to keep reapplying your eye makeup.

Smudging may happen when you rub your eyes or move them around. It could also be that your eyeliner dried out and needs a quick moisture boost. Moisturize your eyeliner by quickly applying a layer of cream or gel over the pencil before use.

Your eye color can determine the best eyeliner to achieve your desired look. Let’s find out what’s the best eyeliner shade for each kind of eye color.

1. Eyeliner for Brown Eyes

There are many factors to consider when choosing eyeliner for brown eyes. The natural pigmentation of the eye, hair color, skin, and makeup all contribute to the final look.

Eyeliner with a shimmer would be perfect for a natural daytime look. It will give your eyes light and sparkle but not too much that it will look unnatural during daytime hours.

A black liner is a good choice for nighttime or more glamorous events. It makes your eyes appear wide and deep, like you were wearing eye shadow with more depth.

2. Eyeliner for Black Eyes

There are different recommendations when choosing the right eyeliner for black eyes. For example, some recommend liquid eyeliner because it will give you a more robust line than a pencil. Others recommend using a pencil as a base and smudging it with liquid eyeliner to make your eyes pop.

Depending on the shape of your eyes and personal preference, use liquid eyeliner for a more intense liner. If you want more of a natural look, then a pencil would be better for you. Two affordable brown eyeliners that will make your black eyes pop are the:

  • Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eye Pencil and
  • Trinny London Eye Liner.

Note that these eyeliners are not appropriate for black eyes only but also for people with dark brown eyes and light brown eyes.

The key is to find a liner that is light enough in color so that it doesn’t overpower the natural coloring of the eye.

Photo by Hebert Santos on Pexels

3. Eyeliner for Green Eyes

The best eyeliner color tones for green eyes are brown, copper, and goldish tones. These colors will successfully complement your eyes.

If you want to be creative with colors and not stick with the standard black, you can try dark pinkish makeup or a brownish shade. These colors usually look good on green eyes.

4. Eyeliner for Blue Eyes

Many blue-eyed people are often confused in the makeup aisle. When they explore the best eyeliner for their eye color, they have to go through a lot testing and practice to get it right.

If you have blue eyes, the best type of eyeliner is light silver or white. These will make them stand out without being overpowering or too dark. If you want your eyes to stand out more, you could use a silver or white highlighter.

5. Eyeliner for Gray Eyes

Gray eyes are scarce; there aren’t many recommendations on what eyeliners to use for this eye color. Some eyeliner shades that go well with this color are brown, black, silver, and pearly white.

6. Eyeliner for Hazel Eyes

Hazel eyes is often tricky to match with colors and styles because they are not common. Some eyeliner colors that work well in combination with hazel eyes are brown, green, olive, gold, and bronze.

Which Eyeliner Makes Your Eyes Look Bigger?

The answer to this question is not as simple since it becomes a subjective matter. It’s more about the shape of your eyes and what you’re trying to do.

If you want to create a more dramatic smoky eye, black eyeliner may be a good choice. The smoky eye is dark, and the color black will naturally make your eyes look a little bit bigger compared to other colors like brown.

Something like brown eyeliner may be your best bet if you want a subtle change.

Photo by Ashley Piszek on Unsplash


Most of the time, the eyes are the main focal point of your makeup look. When deciding what eyeliner color to wear, many people have difficulties in determining if they should use black or brown.

We know that both colors will look great on your eyes, but they will create different effects. Brown is a softer color that would be better if you are looking for something subtle and natural. Black is bolder and has a more dramatic effect.

The best eyeliner to use also depends on what color your eyes are. We hope the color combinations recommended in this article will help you narrow down your choices.

Keep being AllDayChic!

Tags : beauty tipsEye makeupeyelinerLiquid Eyeliner

Leave a Response